e-learningsite.com

free essays
Uncategorized

Comparison and Contrast of Nathaniel Hawthorne and Flannery O`Connor stories

Comparisonand Contrast of Nathaniel Hawthorne and Flannery O`Connor stories

Comparisonand Contrast of Nathaniel Hawthorne and Flannery O`Connor stories

Thispaperseeksto discuss,compareandcontrastHawthorne`s &quotYoung Goodman Brown&quot andO`Connor`s &quotA Goodman is Hard To Find.&quot NathanielHawthorne andFlannery O`Connor storiesbothcan be seento havethemesof evil,sinandpervasiveness in all thepeople,in thebook.Evildoingandhypocrisycan alsobe seento manifestitself within allpeoplein theplay.Trueevilis merelybeyond an actoran emotionitis an existencethat coversone`swholebeing.Manyauthorstryto depictshowevilbutnevercapturethefullinwardness of it.Storiesof&nbsp AGoodman is Hard to Find&quot by Flannery O` Connor and &quotYoungGoodman Brown &quot by Nathaniel Hawthorne evidentlyillustratepureevil.

Compareandcontrasttherepresentationof evilinHawthorne`s &quotYoung Goodman Brown&quot andO`Connor`s &quotA Goodman is Hard To Find&quot

Comparisonin bothHawthorne`s &quotYoung Goodman Brown&quot andO`Connor`s &quotA Goodman is Hard To Find&quotevilactscan be seenwidely.Theevilthatdisplaysthecharactersin thetwo storiescan be seento be differentbutefficient.During thesetimes,thecharacterschangedtheir facades to showtheir trueselves.Itcan evenbe concludedthatthethemeof thesetwo storiescan be howworstsituationsleadsto a callforselfdiscovery.Thisthoughtleadsthereaderto seetheideathat,sonsureoccasionsevilhas to manifestin orderforusto genuinely understandourselvesandthepeoplearound us (O`Connor &amp Asals, 1993).

Hawthorne`s&quotYoung Goodman Brown&quot

NathanielHawthorne’ “Young Goodman Brown,” disclosesresemblanceof theBiblical underlying evilin man,through a troubling dreamof a Puritan manwhotravelsinto evilandis pushedto analyzethenatureandextentof evilin thehumanrace.In thestoryof Hawthornes’ &quotYoung Goodman Brown&quot theauthorusestheSatanic images,in humanformto presentevil.Thisuseof imagesof Satan in thehumanbodyquicklyshowsthedegreeof evilamong theinhabitantsof Salem town.Thecharacterquicklyrevealstheaccuratenatureof thetowndwellersby openlysayingit.Thishugeamountof informationopenlydepictedcannot be fullyunderstoodby Goodman Brown. In his circumstance,Goodman Brown could not bearwith theimperfectionshegotpresentedwith andcould seetheevilin himself andothers. Thisabruptrealizationof evilcrushedhis previouslypuredisposition(O`Connor &amp Asals, 1993).

HawthornedepictedGoodman as proofof mans’ evilnatureby showinghoweasilyevena dedicatedPuritan getstemptedandinfluencedby a completestranger.Thisstrangercan be seensymbolically to depictthedevilamong menin thetextthedevil among men in the text.Theauthorbeginsto introducetheDevil instantlyas tryingto persuadeGoodman to followhim longthejourney.By leavinghis wifeandFaith to beginthejourney,Goodman symbolically meantgoingleavinghis strongbelievein God andfollowingtheDevil. ThemerefactthatGoodman leftwithout consideringhis wifeFaith’s warningdepictsthelackof considerationforhis ownbelievesin God andhis fellowmen. Thisbaredisregard thatGoodman showscan be evidenceof theeasyabilityof manto chooseevilover good.In contrast,Goodman showsclearlyhis confidenceandassurancelessexplicitly. Goodman self-assuredly regardshis faithandwifeas a personof virtue.Hestatesthather wifecan be a blessedangelon earthGoodmans’ faithloveandassurancein his wife`shonestyandloveleadshim to makea comparisonof her andangels(O`Connor &amp Asals, 1993).

O`Connor`s&quotA Goodman is Hard To Find&quot

O`Connor`shandlingof charactersin thepiecestrengthensher opinionof a manas a failed creature.Thestorydepictsthedestructionof a normalfamilyby three convictswhogotaway..Theclimaxof thestoryregardsan offerof graceandtheacceptanceof thegiftby thegrandmotheras a resultof thedivinemanifestationshewentthrough justbefore her death.Theoccurrencewhich contributedto thatclimax,nevertheless,generatemuchof thecuriosityandinterestof thestory.Thestoryallowsthereader`sfirstpictureof thefamilyas dissensionanddisrespectful which portrays’thefamilymembersrelationshipwith eachother(O`Connor &amp Asals, 1993).

Thegrandmother`sexcessiveprideandself-centeredattitudeare madeclearat theearlystagesof thestoryin essenceshowingtheevilthatexistsevenin families.Ratherthan willingto gowith thefamilyon a plannedtripto Florida, shedesiresto paysomeof her &quotconnections&quota visitin eastTennessee. Asthestoryprogresses,one getsto knowthatBailey is her onlyson.Thisactcan be viewedas informationwhich preventsa possiblemisinterpretationof thegrandmother`slastearthbound words,&quotYou are one of my children,.&quotThesewordstherebykeepthereaderfrom missingtheactof graceat thecloseof thestory.In her effortsto makea familygoto Tennessee insteadof Florida, thegrandmothercan be seento usethestoryof thelooseconvict,theMisfit. Thisactclearlyshowshowevilin theplaydepictsitself through thegrandmotheras shetriesto scareBailey her soninto changinghis mind.AlthoughBailey her sondoesnot respondto her (therebydemonstratinga completedisrespectforher. Thisactagainshowstheevilin thestorysince it`sexpectedthata sonshould obeytheparent(O`Connor &amp Asals, 1993).

Thisincidentallowsforan ironicadvancedindicationto theendof thestory.Itbecomesinterestingto notethatFlannery O`Connor includesinformationas thestoryprogressesthatmakesitpossibleas an alternative explanationforthes finalactionsby thegrandmother,thiscould alsobe seenin theHawthornes’ storyof “Young Goodman Brown.&quot In thewholestory,evilgotrepresentedin manyoccasionmakingboththestoriesquitesimilar.Themerepresenceof a misfitalsocan be a clearindicatorof theevilin thatsocietysince thereexistindividualswhowerenot okay with thelaw.

Conclusion

Whenpeoplebecomeconfident,theycan be sureabout thefactsornatureof something. However,thesurenessandaccuracyof thatthingdoesnot makethefactsornaturetrue.Consequently, faithin someoccasionscausessomeone to believeobservationsorspeculationsas facts.Intheshortstories&quotYoung Goodman Brown&quot by Nathaniel Hawthorne and&quotGood Country People,&quot by Flannery O` Connor,theauthorsrevealthatfaithandbelievecan makea personfailto noticethedeception.Inconclusion,thetwo storiescan be seento havesimilarityfeaturesandat thesametimecontrastingfeatures.Someof themajorsimilaritiescan be thatof evilfeaturesthat can be seenbeingmanifestedin thetwo characters.

References

O`Connor,F., &amp Asals, F. (1993). Agood man is hard to find.New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press.